


Property Management in
Fountain Square
Looking for a reliable property management company in Fountain Square? CityPlace offers local expertise, flat-rate pricing, and hands-on support for property owners and investors. Whether you have a single-family home or a small portfolio, we help you manage your rental with ease.
Why Property Owners in
Fountain Square Choose CityPlace
- Local presence, trusted by Fountain Square-area landlords
- Flat $60/month management fee
- Quick response times and in-house maintenance
- Deep knowledge of the tenant pool and rentals in Fountain Square






Neighborhood Snapshot
Fountain Square is a vibrant, historic cultural district just southeast of downtown Indianapolis, known for its artsy energy, historic architecture, and exceptional walkability. The neighborhood features notable landmarks like the century‑old Fountain Square Fountain, located at Virginia Avenue and Prospect Street—an enduring symbol of the area’s identity. The Murphy Arts Center adds creative flair, featuring galleries and live‑music venues in vintage industrial buildings. For green space, residents enjoy Stacy Park, a small, shaded playground with picnic spots, perfect for families living in the area.
Connectivity is excellent thanks to the Indianapolis Cultural Trail—a popular pedestrian and bike route that links Fountain Square with key downtown districts. Commuting is seamless thanks to the Red Line rapid-transit bus route that runs directly through Fountain Square along Virginia Avenue. Walkers and cyclists love Fountain Square—with a Walk Score at 84, Transit 41, and Bike Score at 97. Fountain Square is incredibly walkable, transit-accessible, and a biker’s paradise.
Thanks to Fountain Square’s mix of historic early 20th-century bungalows and modern renovations, median rents hover around $1,600/month. With steady demand from young professionals and creatives, it’s a top neighborhood for value-add investment. The average home value is around $312,500–$490,000, and the median household income is about $55,375, with a population of ~37,000 residents.
Our Services in Fountain Square
Rental Marketing
Tenant Screening
Maintenance Coordination
Rent Collection
Financial Reporting
What Makes Us Different from Other
Fountain Square Property Managers
A fixed monthly fee (only $60)—no hidden costs or percentages
Local presence with real-time familiarity of the neighborhood
We’re investors too—we manage like owners would
Happy clients in Fountain Square


Ready to Rent Your Fountain Square Property?
Contact CityPlace today for a free rental analysis in Indianapolis’ historic, creative Fountain Square. Discover how we can help you maximize occupancy and returns for your listing.
FAQ Section
Rent in Fountain Square tends to hover around $1,600 per month. As of June 2025, the average apartment rent in the area was approximately $1,634/month. Current listings reflect a range from around $900/mo for smaller spaces to $2,700/mo+ for larger units or houses, depending on features and condition.
Fountain Square attracts a creative, urban, and largely millennial tenant base—think young professionals, artists, and renters who value walkability, affordability, and cultural vibrancy. The neighborhood’s proximity to bars, boutique shops, galleries, and functional transit like the Red Line makes it especially appealing for those seeking a lively, well-connected urban lifestyle.
Given Fountain Square’s popularity and central location, listings with strong presentation and competitive pricing often fill quickly. CityPlace’s marketing—professional photos, optimized listings, and access to pre-qualified local applicants—typically places high-quality tenants approximately within 30 days of listing, often faster in high-demand periods.
