Property Management in
EAgle Creek, IN
Looking for a reliable property management company in Eagle Creek? CityPlace offers local expertise, flat-rate pricing, and hands-on support for property owners and investors. Whether you have a single-family home or a small portfolio, we help you manage your rental with ease.
Why Property Owners in
Eagle Creek Choose CityPlace
- Fixed $60/month flat fee—no percentage surprises
- Responsive local team with a hands-on investor mindset
- In-house maintenance for timely and reliable services
- Deep understanding of Eagle Creek’s community dynamic and housing market
Neighborhood Snapshot
The Eagle Creek neighborhood is unique in Indianapolis due to its proximity to global food offerings, cultural spaces, and famous sports facilities. But what makes it exceptional is its namesake—Eagle Creek Park and Eagle Creek Reservoir. The park is approximately 1,400 acres, making it one of the largest urban parks in the United States. The park serves as a nature preserve, and offers many amenities, including: 10 miles of walking paths and bike trails; boat ramps; a sailboat marina and rentals; fishing areas; and a golf course. It also includes organizations such as the Peace Learning Center, Ornithology Center, and Indianapolis Rowing Center.
To the east of the Eagle Creek area is the International Marketplace neighborhood, a stretch of 38th Street that is home to 120 ethnic restaurants and grocery stores within 4 square miles. To the southeast is the town of Speedway, Indiana, a community with unique charm steeped in the tradition of Race Day and the Indianapolis 500—and beyond.
The Eagle Creek neighborhood encompasses all of Eagle Creek Park. It stretches from Raceway Road to the west and I 465 and 65 to its east. The southernmost border is I 74 and its northern border is near Traders Point and 86th Street.
The average home value is $254,000 and the median household income is $78,500, with a population of 15,300 residents.
Renters make up 52% of household occupants, while 48% of residents own their homes.
Our Services in Eagle Creek
Rental Marketing
Tenant Screening
Maintenance Coordination
Rent Collection
Financial Reporting
What Makes Us Different from Other
Eagle Creek, IN Property Managers
Flat-rate pricing to provide predictable budgeting
Local presence gives us fast, personalized service
In-house maintenance keeps downtime and costs low
Investor perspective means we care for your property like our own
Ready to Rent Your Eagle Creek Property?
Contact CityPlace for a free rental analysis tailored to Eagle Creek, Indiana. Let us help you maximize occupancy and rental income.
FAQ Section
Single-Family homes average around $2,100/month, as of listings from January 2026.
Townhomes average $1,300/month, and you can find some townhomes within apartment building communities.
Apartments in Eagle Creek, based on listings in January 2026, can be an average rent of: 1-bedroom units near $1,000–$1,100, 2-bedrooms near $1,300–$1,400, and 3-bedrooms typically at $1,500+. Apartment communities include Astoria Park, Idlewood, Wylde at Eagle Creek, Center Point, Park at Eagle Creek, Pier 39, Deercross, Enclave, and more.
With its unique location between the northwest side and the International Marketplace, the Eagle Creek neighborhood has a diverse mix of residents. The population skews younger, with 22% being between the ages of 25 and 44. Families make up 23% of the population. With Eagle Creek being adjacent.
Given Eagle Creek’s unique resources and availability for rentals, listings with strong presentation and competitive pricing often fill quickly. CityPlace’s marketing—professional photos, optimized listings, and access to pre-qualified local applicants—typically places high-quality tenants approximately within 30 days of listing, often faster in high-demand periods.
CONNECT WITH OUR TEAM
Looking for your dream rental? This isn’t the form for you–click here to fill out a rental form!